A tide of information on politics, environment, and ocean issues

News and information from Washington, DC

Congressional committee determines that all the major oil companies are ill positioned to protect Walruses in the event of a Gulf of Mexico oil spill….or something to that effect

leave a comment »

the Mythical Gulf of Mexico Walrus

The often cited mythical Gulf of Mexico Walrus is well protected according to the oil majors' Gulf of Mexico oil spill response plans

Today on Capitol Hill the House Energy and Commerce subcommittee on Energy and Environment is holding a hearing on oil spill response plans of the five oil majors in the U.S.  Congress requested that Exxon, Shell, BP, Chevron, Conoco Phillips provide copies of their response plans to the Energy and Commerce Committee.  

To no great surprise, the plans are more of less cookie cutter response plans, including some references to impacts on animals would only be found in the Gulf of Mexico in a zoo or an aquarium, such as the now well reported Gulf of Mexico walruses referenced in the five oil companies’ response plans. Maybe these sorts of errors occur when your experts are no longer among the living. Yes, experts, including Dr. Peter Lutz from the Florida Atlantic University, who have long passed are cited as experts in the oil response plans. And it is heartening to know that if one has questions about marine mammal impacts that you can go to the oil spill response plan and get a phone number for a deceased scientist. That’s sure to be a long, long distance call. 

The five oil spill majors' covers from the Oil Spill Gulf of Mexico Response Plans all use the same photos

The five oil spill majors' covers from the Oil Spill Gulf of Mexico Response Plans all use the same photos

Humor is easy when the oil companies put targets on themselves asking Congress to take pot shots at them. U.S. House of Representatives Energy and Commerce Committee Subcommittee on Energy and Environment Subcommittee Chairman Ed Markey highlighted a graphic of the covers of five oil majors’ response plan book covers and noted that not only were the contents largely the product of a copy-paste exercise, the cover art itself was the same with the exception of the overall color tone of the photos. Chairman Markey added that the state of the art technology brought to bear in the production on these plans seems to be the technology involved in a Xerox machine. 

But jokes and pot shots aside, perhaps it should be no surprise that the documents are quite similar. Personally, rather than each company reinventing the wheel and wasting funds on startup costs for projects whose intention is to provide a robust spill response plan, I would like to see those companies who operate in a particular geographic area spend their funds on getting the best of the best experts and updating their documents frequently to reflect knowledge gained from operations around the globe. 

For instance, the deepwater spills in Mexico, and disturbingly recently in Australia, should have triggered rewrites in the response plans. And the triggers should have been pulled both by the oil majors, for a simple sake of protecting their ultimate liability in the case of another deepwater spill in the U.S., and also by government regulators. Perhaps the $75 million liability cap has resulted in a lax attitude in the oil companies drilling in U.S. waters, although there is no smoking gun at this point to prove that theory. And there is not yet an explanation about why the U.S. government hasn’t reacted to other deepwater spills around the globe. 

Many questions and thus far there are few answers. The Presidential Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling Commission will have its hand full looking at a wide range of issues. And with a call for a quick turn around and target of six-months for the delivery of their findings, it will be a busy summer and fall for the seven Commission members.

The author is a scientist by training and the owner of W.H. Nuckols Consulting, an environmental policy firm.


Written by Will Nuckols

June 15, 2010 at 10:36 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: